Season Long Grades (The Athletic)

[Alaska Darin]

Another one from The Athletic:

https://theathletic.com/2306434/2021/01/06/bills-dolphins-taron-johnson-antonio-williams-draft/?article_source=search&search_query=tremaine edmunds

There's quite a bit in this article besides the chart.

Interesting chart (take for what it's worth):

Season-long grades

 

Bills Season-Long Grades (Week 17)

 

                                                         Position/Grade/Snaps/Last Week

 

1	Josh Allen	QB	3.48	1035	1
2	Stefon Diggs	WR	3.48	965	2
3	Dion Dawkins	LT	3.41	1032	3
4	Matt Milano	WLB	3.34	335	4
5	Cole Beasley	WR	3.22	680	5
6	John Brown	WR	3.19	453	7
7	Jon Feliciano	G/C	3.17	571	6
8	Tre’Davious White	CB	3.15	878	8
9	Ed Oliver	DT	3.15	578	9
10	Micah Hyde	FS	3.10	1010	13
11	Jerry Hughes	DE	3.10	629	11
12	Devin Singletary	RB	3.10	621	10
13	Jordan Poyer	SS	3.08	938	15
14	Zack Moss	RB	3.07	403	14
15	Mitch Morse	C	3.06	878	12
16	Vernon Butler	DT	3.03	534	17
17	Daryl Williams	RT	3.02	1048	16
18	Gabriel Davis	WR	3.02	797	18
19	Justin Zimmer	DT	2.99	276	19
20	Isaiah McKenzie	WR	2.98	270	23
21	Tyler Kroft	TE	2.88	298	20
22	A.J. Epenesa	DE	2.87	291	24
23	Mario Addison	DE	2.84	606	21
24	Cody Ford	LG	2.83	383	22
25	Darryl Johnson	DE	2.79	225	NR
26	Harrison Phillips	DT	2.76	332	25
27	Taron Johnson	CB	2.73	825	27
28	Dawson Knox	TE	2.72	487	26
29	Tremaine Edmunds	MLB	2.68	911	29
30	Dean Marlowe	SS	2.68	230	NR
31	Quinton Jefferson	DT	2.65	534	28
32	Trent Murphy	DE	2.65	343	31
33	Josh Norman	CB	2.63	344	30
34	A.J. Klein	SLB	2.54	652	33
35	Ike Boettger	LG	2.51	622	32
36	Levi Wallace	CB	2.48	612	34
37	Brian Winters	RG	2.13	616	35

[Ann]

Wow they were harsh Bills graders against the Dolphins.

 

[Alaska Darin]

2 minutes ago, Ann said:

Wow they were harsh Bills graders against the Dolphins.

One of the things I've gleaned from following them is they're pretty fair.  The result of a specific play game might be favorable but that doesn't mean all 11 players did their job.  It can be mostly taken with a grain of salt since we really don't know what's coached and a specific grade could be completely wrong just based on that.

 

All that said, I wasn't surprised at all at the Top nor Bottom season grades.  It mostly lines up with how I see it.

[Ann]

2 minutes ago, Alaska Darin said:

One of the things I've gleaned from following them is they're pretty fair.  The result of a specific play game might be favorable but that doesn't mean all 11 players did their job.  It can be mostly taken with a grain of salt since we really don't know what's coached and a specific grade could be completely wrong just based on that.

 

All that said, I wasn't surprised at all at the Top nor Bottom season grades.  It mostly lines up with how I see it.

I was just referring to the Dolphins game grades.  Grading Isaiah McKenzie and Antonio Williams an A- on the surface, seems a bit harsh.  Yeah, I know an A- is excellent, but an A is even better. 🙂